LIFE BEYOND FIRST CLASS
ESTATES
GULF-FRONT SERENITY
Osmyrrah is a rare waterfront retreat offering indoor–outdoor living with sweeping ocean views, guest cottage privacy, and a private beach walkway on an exclusive eight-mile barrier island.
3201 Casey Key Rd, Casey Key, Florida
$3,995,000
JESSICA HALL
On the coveted shores of Casey Key, where white sands stretch endlessly and the Gulf shimmers like liquid sapphire, lies Osmyrrah—a rare beachfront retreat designed for those who crave both privacy and connection to the sea. Tucked away on an exclusive barrier island with fewer than 400 homes, Osmyrrah embodies the essence of coastal tranquility, offering four bedrooms, four bathrooms, and 3,273 square feet of elevated living space that embraces the rhythm of the waves.
Casey Key itself is a world apart—an eight-mile sanctuary known for its natural beauty and understated luxury. Here, there are no high-rises or crowded beaches. Instead, the island moves at its own serene pace, with the rhythm of sea and sky creating an intimate, private atmosphere. Residents enjoy the rare distinction of Gulf ownership to the mean high-water line combined with deeded bay access, granting the best of both worlds: sunrise over Little Sarasota Bay and sunset melting into the Gulf. Dolphins and manatees often make appearances just offshore, while osprey circle above the dunes and sea turtles nest and hatch along the beach each season. Life here is deeply connected to the environment and refreshingly removed from the ordinary.
Within Osmyrrah, every detail is crafted for harmony with its surroundings. Walls of glass and soaring ceilings invite the Gulf indoors, while an open-concept great room and dining area flow seamlessly into a generous kitchen, where endless water views serve as a daily backdrop. Step onto the open deck for sunning or grilling, or retreat to the expansive screened-in porch, where warm breezes and fiery sunsets frame every gathering.
The gulf-front primary suite is a private haven, featuring lofty ceilings, a luxurious renovated bath, and a spacious walk-in closet. A guest bedroom, full bath, and private office complete the north wing. On the south side of the home, a second large primary suite offers its own bath, walk-in closet, and full laundry room. For extended stays, a charming 360-square-foot guest cottage provides high ceilings, a living area, a full bath, and a private entrance. Guests will also enjoy a refreshing outdoor shower, perfectly placed near the beach.
Beyond the interiors, Osmyrrah is equally suited to adventure and relaxation. A two-car garage, new HVAC system (2025), roof (2019), and a spacious under-home storage area provide room for kayaks, paddleboards, and coastal toys. A private walkway winds through native vegetation to a beachfront deck and down to the sand. Here, the experience feels more like a secluded Caribbean escape.
Although Casey Key feels worlds away, the location offers exceptional convenience. South of the iconic Blackburn Point swing bridge, the property is minutes from golf, fine dining, boutique shopping, and the nationally acclaimed Pine View School. In nearby Venice, historic avenues lined with cafés and galleries evoke Old Florida charm. A short drive north brings you to Sarasota, home to world-class cultural attractions, including the Ringling Museum, Sarasota Ballet, and a thriving culinary scene.
At Osmyrrah, life is lived to the rhythm of the tides. From mornings spent watching dolphins leap in the surf to evenings painted in shades of coral and gold, this estate offers more than a home. It is a story of coastal living at its finest, waiting for its next chapter.
3201 Casey Key Rd, Casey Key, Florida is offered at $3,995,000.
For more information or to schedule a private viewing, please contact:
Judie Berger, PA, ABR, GRI
Premier Sotheby’s International Realty
T: +1 941.928.3424
E: Judie.Berger@PremierSIR.com
W: www.homesofsarasota.com
Join our mailing list to receive curated updates, special features, and invitations to events that define the world of the discerning few.
Sign up today and never miss what’s next.